23 listings found
2436 CR 416N
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 3,206 SqFt · $561/SqFt
Days on Market: 99
Cumulative Days on Market: 1,326
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: NA
Year built: 1994
Garage: Yes 2 vehicles
Lot Size (in acres): 78.00
Great location/neighbors. This /2 house on78 acres backs up to nature preserve. Beautiful grandfather oaks and wildlife including cows, deer, wild turkey among others. House is situated on a fenced five acre plot with electric gate. Set back two tenths of a mile from road. House has two fireplaces. One is wood burning and the other is propane. Large screened porch off master bedroom. Surrounded by beautiful pastures that are fenced and cross fenced. Good access to Turnpike, I-75 and CR 44. Easy drive to Orlando and Tampa. Nearby towns include Bushnell, Inverness, Villages and ... Read more....»
4777 CR 306A
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 1 Half Bath · 2,244 SqFt · $209/SqFt
Days on Market: 295
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: SUNSET SHORES
Year built: 2023
Garage: Yes 2 vehicles
Waterfront: Yes
Welcome to this stunning modern Craftsman-style 3BR/2.5BA 2,244+/-SQ FT home, located along the tranquil banks of a private canal. With its timeless design, exceptional craftsmanship, and breathtaking water views, this home offers the perfect blend of elegance and comfort. The canal leads out to The Withlacoochee which spans all the way to the Gulf of Mexico and connects to Lake Panasoffkee. Known for its massive 4,460 acres, Lake Panasoffkee offers a perfect blend of rural settings with various activities such as fishing, trails, swimming, boat rides, and so much more. Located right off SR 44 this home is centrally located to ... Read more....»
897 CR 454
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
2 Bed · 1 Bath · 1 Half Bath · 1,514 SqFt · $297/SqFt
Days on Market: 1
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: PANASOFFKEE ESTATES
Year built: 1959
Garage: No
Waterfront: Yes
Waterfront retreat! This mid century block home is encompassed by over 300ft of Canal Frontage and just a stones through from the Lake. Boasting over 2/3 of an acre, a massive concrete waterside dock, a separate floating dock, multiple carports, a 18x24 workshop/garage with its own 200amp service, partially fenced yard, 30 amp RV hookup, and an extra 300SqFt livable building featuring its own bathroom, this property has it all and so much more! Inside you’ll find 2 bedrooms 1 1/2 bath and a whole lot of upgrades! Whole interior repainted in 2025, roof redone in 2021, new flooring in ... Read more....»
4192 CR 400
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
4 Bed · 2 Bath · 1,940 SqFt · $231/SqFt
Days on Market: 3
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: IDLEWILD PARK
Year built: 1971
Garage: No
Waterfront: Yes
LAKE FRONT with miles of wide open views. You will love the views. Lots of open water and wildlife to enjoy. It's approximately 1 mile directly across the lake. On the other side is Lake Panasoffkee Wildlife Management Area. Lake Panasoffkee is approx 1 mile wide and 5 miles long. The north, south and east sides have lots of marshes and flooded cypress. A large portion of the lake is undeveloped and will remain undeveloped. If you love nature, this lake is for you. Great fishing, lots of birds and other wildlife. From the house you boat down the Outlet ... Read more....»
2377 NW 34TH PLACE
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
2 Bed · 2 Bath · 864 SqFt · $492/SqFt
Days on Market: 6
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: OLIVEPALM SUB
Year built: 2007
Garage: No
Waterfront: Yes
Located in Lake Panasoffkee, FL 33538, this unique multi-parcel offering presents a significant opportunity for waterfront development or a private family compound. Combined, the two properties (Parcel F30A042 and F30A036) provide approximately 208 feet of canal frontage and approximately 1.66 total acres of land. Property 1: 2377 NW 34th Place (.77 Acres) This parcel serves as the primary residential site with extensive marine infrastructure: Main Residence: A stilt-style home featuring 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The layout includes two bedrooms and one bath on the upper level and a second bath downstairs in the Florida/laundry room area. The exterior requires maintenance to ... Read more....»
876 CR 467
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 1,728 SqFt · $230/SqFt
Days on Market: 179
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: LAKE SHORE PARK
Year built: 2015
Garage: Yes 2 vehicles
Waterfront: Yes
Waterfront- Nestled along a great fishing canal that opens up to the stunning Lake Panasoffkee. This custom built 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers a spacious open floor plan with soaring ceilings and recessed lighting throughout. Each bedroom includes a walk-in closet, offering ample storage space, and there's additional built-in storage thoughtfully placed throughout the home.The kitchen is a chef’s dream—featuring granite countertops, real wood cabinetry, Travertine flooring, a walk in pantry and a large breakfast bar with seating that's perfect for entertaining family and friends. The primary bedroom is very generous in size that has a very functional bathroom and walk in closet ... Read more....»
1118 CR 440
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
5 Bed · 3 Bath · 1 Half Bath · 2,635 SqFt · $138/SqFt
Days on Market: 90
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: TRACYS PT 3RD ADD
Year built: 1974
Garage: Yes 2 vehicles
Private Pool: Yes
Welcome to 1118 CR 440 in Lake Panasoffkee, a rare find offering 5 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, and over 2,600 sq. ft. of living space perfect for large families, multigenerational living, or those who love to entertain. This two-story home features a bright and open second floor with a large living room, four bedrooms, and two full bathrooms. The master suite includes its own private side porch accessed via a sliding glass door, ideal for peaceful mornings or quiet evenings. A front balcony adds charming curb appeal and extra space to relax. Downstairs, the first floor offers flexible living arrangements with an apartment-style layout featuring a private bedroom, living ... Read more....»
645 CR 485A
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
2 Bed · 2 Bath · 720 SqFt · $486/SqFt
New Listing!!! Days on Market: 1
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: PANASOFFKEE RETREATS
Year built: 2024
Garage: No
Waterfront: Yes
If you’ve been searching for a well-built waterfront home in Lake Panasoffkee with direct canal access to the lake, this property deserves your attention. Located on a canal just off Lake Panasoffkee, this home offers peaceful water views, excellent construction, and true Florida outdoor living. Constructed with durable metal siding and roofing, this home was built with strength and longevity in mind. Inside, you’ll find an open-concept layout with vaulted ceilings that make the main living area feel bright and spacious. Natural light pours in through multiple windows, showcasing clean lines, modern finishes, and a comfortable lake-house feel. The kitchen is thoughtfully ... Read more....»
1022 CR 463B
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 1,632 SqFt · $183/SqFt
Days on Market: 110
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: HOLIDAY HAVEN
Year built: 2005
Garage: Yes 2 vehicles
MOTIVATED SELLERS!! Discover your slice of Florida living in this beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath home tucked into a quiet cul-de-sac in Lake Panasoffkee. This single-family gem offers comfort, style, and versatility. It is the ideal balance of move-in readiness and opportunity. With fresh flooring and lots of space to personalize, it’s ready for you to make it your own. Step outside and you’ll quickly find that the porch is the favorite spot to be — perfect for sipping morning coffee, relaxing in the evening breeze, or simply soaking in the peace and quiet of this tranquil neighborhood. The generously sized ... Read more....»
4255 CR 309
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
4 Bed · 2 Bath · 1,684 SqFt · $172/SqFt
Days on Market: 723
County: Sumter
Subdiv/Community Name: Not Applicable
Legal Subdivision Name: SUNSET SHORES
Year built: 1979
Garage: Yes 2 vehicles
Nice 4/2 home on a quiet dead end street. Home is rented and needs 48 hrs notice for an appointment, please.
1251 CR 436
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
2 Bed · 2 Bath · 1,532 SqFt · $180/SqFt
Days on Market: 179
County: Sumter
Subdiv/Community Name: Not Applicable
Legal Subdivision Name: EMERT ACRES
Year built: 2000
Garage: Yes 2 vehicles
Waterfront: Yes
Make sure to check out the Virtual Tour for a 3D Model w/ Walkthrough, Floor Plan w/ Measurements, Video, & more! Relaxed Florida Living Vibes... you got them all day and night at this peaceful canal front home just 500 feet from the open spring fed Lake Panasoffkee! This 2bedroom PLUS bonus room, 2bath home, with huge screened in back patio, built in 2000 (with a 2019 roof & 2023 AC!) spans 1,532sqft of living space, with 2,488sqft total under roof on a .24-acre lot. Before you even step through the front door, you’ll be greeted by a screened-in porch, ... Read more....»
1119 CR 457
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
2 Bed · 2 Bath · 1,758 SqFt · $153/SqFt
Days on Market: 105
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: 2ND ADD TRACYS PT
Year built: 1989
Garage: No
Waterfront: Yes
Canal-front charm meets practical comfort in this solid block and stucco home offering approximately 1,758 square feet of living space and set on approx 1/3 acre lot at the end of a quiet street. Featuring two bedrooms, two full bathrooms, and an extended enclosed bonus room. Recent updates include a newer metal roof and a newer central A/C in 2024 and tile flooring throughout. The updated kitchen includes newer appliances, ready for everyday use. Step outside to a screened lanai perfect quiet relaxation, a spacious back yard with two sheds offering extra storage, and a detached 1-bedroom in-law suite with ... Read more....»
2346 CR 401
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 1,131 SqFt · $230/SqFt
Days on Market: 3
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: N/A
Year built: 1966
Garage: No
Waterfront: Yes
Welcome to this beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 2-bath home, located just one lot in from Lake Panasoffkee on a canal. This property offers the perfect blend of comfortable living and access to some of Central Florida’s best fishing and boating. The home has been recently remodeled and features updated finishes throughout, making it move-in ready. The finished bonus room provides flexible space ideal for a home office, guest room, hobby room, or additional living area. Outside, enjoy a two-car carport with storage room and a peaceful canal-side setting with quick, easy water access while maintaining added privacy being set one lot off the ... Read more....»
2276 CR 423 Lot 4
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 1,102 SqFt · $213/SqFt
Days on Market: 131
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: INDIAN ESTATES
Year built: 2025
Garage: No
Under Construction. Under Construction. Under Construction. Charming New Construction Home in Indian Estates Welcome to your dream home in Lake Panasoffkee, Florida! This brand-new three-bedroom, two-bathroom home is currently under construction and offers an unbeatable combination of style, comfort, and convenience. Featuring durable Hardy Board siding, architectural shingles, quarts countertops, stainless steel appliances. Luxury vinyl plank flooring, LED lighting, among many other finishing, this home is designed to impress. Nestled in the sought-after Indian Estates neighborhood, you’ll enjoy the peace of small-town living while being just minutes away from The Villages, I-75, and the exciting new Middleton campus. Offered at ... Read more....»
2474 CR 423 Lot 29
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 1,062 SqFt · $220/SqFt
Days on Market: 44
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: INDIAN ESTATES
Year built: 2026
Garage: No
Under Construction. Under Construction. Under Construction. Under Construction. Charming New Construction Home in Indian Estates This model is being built on multiple lots (16, 18, 20, 29) Welcome to your dream home in Lake Panasoffkee, Florida! This brand-new three-bedroom, two-bathroom home is currently under construction and offers an unbeatable combination of style, comfort, and convenience. Featuring durable Hardy Board siding, architectural shingles, quarts countertops, stainless steel appliances. Luxury vinyl plank flooring, LED lighting, among many other finishing, this home is designed to impress. Nestled in the sought-after Indian Estates neighborhood, you’ll enjoy the peace of small-town living while being just ... Read more....»
2370 CR 423 Lot 16
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 1,062 SqFt · $220/SqFt
Days on Market: 201
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: INDIAN ESTATES
Year built: 2025
Garage: No
Under Construction. Under Construction. Charming New Construction Home in Indian Estates This model is being built on multiple lots (16, 18, 20, 29) Welcome to your dream home in Lake Panasoffkee, Florida! This brand-new three-bedroom, two-bathroom home is currently under construction and offers an unbeatable combination of style, comfort, and convenience. Featuring durable Hardy Board siding, architectural shingles, quarts countertops, stainless steel appliances. Luxury vinyl plank flooring, LED lighting, among many other finishing, this home is designed to impress. Nestled in the sought-after Indian Estates neighborhood, you’ll enjoy the peace of small-town living while being just minutes away from The ... Read more....»
2381 CR 423 Lot 41
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 1,068 SqFt · $215/SqFt
Days on Market: 131
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: INDIAN ESTATES
Year built: 2025
Garage: No
Under Construction. Under Construction. Under Construction. Charming New Construction Home in Indian Estates Welcome to your dream home in Lake Panasoffkee, Florida! This brand-new three-bedroom, two-bathroom home is currently under construction and offers an unbeatable combination of style, comfort, and convenience. Featuring durable Hardy Board siding, architectural shingles, quarts countertops, stainless steel appliances. Luxury vinyl plank flooring, LED lighting, among many other finishing, this home is designed to impress. Nestled in the sought-after Indian Estates neighborhood, you’ll enjoy the peace of small-town living while being just minutes away from The Villages, I-75, and the exciting new Middleton campus. Offered at ... Read more....»
951 CR 453
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
2 Bed · 1 Bath · 784 SqFt · $292/SqFt
Days on Market: 212
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: TRACYS POINT
Year built: 1959
Garage: No
Welcome to this adorable 2-bedroom, 1-bath gem in the sought-after Tracy’s Point community. This charming home features a spacious Florida room, RV hook-up, and sits on a rare 3-lot assemblage, offering plenty of space for your boat, golf cart, and all your toys. Enjoy the perks of deeded boat launch access to the pristine waters of Lake Panasoffkee—a spring-fed lake renowned for top-notch fishing including largemouth bass, bluegill, speckled perch, and more. Seller provides flexibility and is willing to convey the property with any combination of 1, 2, or all 3 lots. Perfect for buyers who want options. Reach out for ... Read more....»
2399 CR 423 Lot 43
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 1,068 SqFt · $211/SqFt
Days on Market: 319
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: INDIAN ESTATES
Year built: 2025
Garage: No
Under Construction. Under Construction. New 3-Bedroom, 2-Bathroom Homes in Indian Estates This model is being built on 4 lots (43, 44, 45,46) ***Colors of finishings may vary home to home*** Discover these charming 1,050 sq. ft. homes located in the serene community of Indian Estates, Lake Panasoffkee, Florida. Featuring durable Hardy Board siding, architectural shingles, quarts countertops, stainless steel appliances. Luxury vinyl plank flooring, LED lighting, among many other finishing, this home is designed to impress. Nestled near the beautiful spring-fed Lake Panasoffkee, this community offers a peaceful retreat with convenient access to modern amenities. Enjoy being just minutes from ... Read more....»
2597 NW CR 426F STREET NE
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 1,147 SqFt · $188/SqFt
Days on Market: 6
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: PANA COO CHEE RETREATS
Year built: 2007
Garage: Yes 1 vehicles
ATTENTION All VETERANS,First time home buyers, investors, and any one else looking for an adorable and affordable 3 bedroom and 2 bath home that has been completely redone. It comes on an oversized lot with a good size work shed. Features vinyl flooring every where except in the kitchen and bathrooms which have ceramic tile. Make an appointment today to see this adorable home! You won't be sorry because it is a great value in todays market. All stainless steel appliances in kitchen convey.
853 CR 484
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 930 SqFt · $199/SqFt
Days on Market: 1
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: PANASOFFKEE RETREATS
Year built: 1973
Garage: No
Waterfront: Yes
Whether the sun is shining or not we think there’s a good chance the fish are bitting. Everyone says they want a handyman special. So here you go. Don’t let a little sweat equity stand in the way of you and a new weekend get-a-way. Originally built in 1973, this beauty is showing its age but eager for its next chapter if you give it a chance. Standing tall this wood frame, with a metal roof, stilt home, says bring your toothbrush and your tool box and let’s make a deal. Technically a 2 bedroom home, but an easy conversion ... Read more....»
922 CR 482A
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
3 Bed · 1 Bath · 808 SqFt · $216/SqFt
Days on Market: 7
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: ANGLERS HAVEN
Year built: 1961
Garage: No
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Move-in ready renovated home with deeded boat slip and direct lake access in Lake Panasoffkee. This updated property offers the perfect blend of comfort, value, and Florida lake lifestyle. A rare find in the area, the home includes legal ownership of a private deeded boat slip, providing direct access to Lake Panasoffkee for boating, fishing, and waterfront enjoyment. The interior features a renovated kitchen and bathroom with granite countertops and brand-new appliances, including stove, microwave, and water heater. Mini-split A/C systems provide energy-efficient cooling and individualized climate control throughout the home. Interior laundry area ... Read more....»
2380 NW 34TH PLACE
LAKE PANASOFFKEE FL 33538
Residential / Single Family Residence
1 Bed · 1 Bath · 1,104 SqFt · $158/SqFt
Days on Market: 1
County: Sumter
Legal Subdivision Name: OLIVE PALM
Year built: 1969
Garage: No
This adorable, cozy home is located on a canal that leads to the Lake Panasoffkee Oultet and has been lightly refreshed and is ready for new owners! The current owners have added new blinds throughout the home, new vinyl plank and vinyl tile flooring on the main level, a new stove, sink, faucet and countertop in the kitchen, and a new vanity and medicine cabinet in bathroom. There are 2 fireplaces on the main level (woodburning in the family room and gas in the dinette) and wall units in the family room and bedroom. That's just the inside...there is a ... Read more....»
The information relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the My Florida Regional MLS DBA Stellar MLS. This information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use. It may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.
